Phillies Nuggets: J.T. Realmuto back, 3 catchers and latest on Brandon Marsh

MIAMI — J.T. Realmuto was activated from the injured list prior to Saturday’s game against the Marlins, but both Rafael Marchán and Garrett Stubbs remain on the 26-man roster for the Phillies. 

Instead, the Phillies designated Dylan Moore for assignment. The 33-year-old offered strong defensive flexibility, but had zero hits in 12 at-bats this season. 

Marchán is struggling mightily offensively, as he’s got just four hits in 51 at-bats this year, for an .078 batting average. Nonetheless, he is a strong defender and without any minor-league options, the Phillies have decided to hold onto the 27-year-old. 

Stubbs also can’t be sent to the minors without clearing waivers. He worked on playing positions other than catcher in Spring Training and early on in the Triple-A season, and the Phillies keeping a third catcher suggests they believe he could hold his own in an MLB game 

Interim manager Don Mattingly explained before Saturday's game why the Phillies have decided to keep three catchers for the time being.

"I like the thought of the three catchers, it allows a little bit more freedom with pinch hitting, running," Mattingly said. "Stubby's not a traditional catcher that can't do anything else. He can play second ... he can play third ... he can play left ... he actually runs, he can steal a bag ... he's a good baserunner, good bunter. All the things that role brings, we feel pretty good about Stubby doing it.

"You've seen how much Moore played," Mattingly continued. "That role is not a huge role." 

Don Mattingly explains why the Phillies have opted to keep three catchers for the time being.

(Via @TimKellySports) pic.twitter.com/EHZmSyhq1O

— OnPattison (@OnPattison) May 2, 2026

The Phillies are also aware that Realmuto — who is hitting seventh in Saturday's lineup — is a 35-year-old catcher returning from back spasms. The hope is that he's good to go moving forward, but keeping both Marchán and Stubbs does give them some insurance. 

"The thought of having a third catcher, with where J.T.'s been, we're hoping everything goes perfectly, but you never know," Mattingly said. "And it does give me the flexibility when Marchán plays." 

From the sounds of things, Stubbs isn't a candidate to start at a position other than catcher, but Mattingly believes he could slot in at another position if it's a weird game involving pinch hitters and/or runners and the Phillies need him to go in at second base, third base or left field late for a few innings.  

The Phillies have in the past talked about pacing Realmuto a little bit more behind the plate, and he usually ends up still taking down one of the largest workloads in the sport. Mattingly does seem genuine in wanting to protect Realmuto from himself, though, and he said he's willing to put either Marchán or Stubbs behind the plate on a day off for the starting catcher. If either of them can hit even a little bit, that may make it easier to manage Realmuto's workload. 

The Nuggets

• As we noted latest night, Brandon Marsh didn't sustain a fracture when he got hit on the right elbow by a pitch in the bottom of the seventh inning in Friday night's win. Marsh isn't in the starting lineup Saturday, with Mattingly saying before the game that he's dealing with some inflammation. For what it's worth, Marsh said the pitch actually missed his elbow guard. Mattingly did seem to think it's possible Marsh will be available off the bench Saturday. 

Don Mattingly provides the latest update on Brandon Marsh’s right elbow.

(Via @TimKellySports) pic.twitter.com/TJvFaZvvOf

— OnPattison (@OnPattison) May 2, 2026

• Jhoan Duran did throw a bullpen Saturday at loanDepot Park, though Mattingly was unsure exactly how it went because he was in another meeting at that time. Mattingly said that the Phillies are still deciding how to proceed with Duran in terms of whether he'll need a rehab stint before returning from his left oblique strain. All things seem to be trending in a positive direction, though. 

• Mattingly had some pretty high praise for Zack Wheeler after Friday's win: 

Don Mattingly was asked about getting to see Zack Wheeler up close, and recalled his reaction to seeing him a night after Jacob deGrom when he managed the Marlins.

(Via @TimKellySports) pic.twitter.com/KCfkMURVFN

— OnPattison (@OnPattison) May 2, 2026

Read More Phillies Content At OnPattison

1. What will Donnie Baseball look like? Mattingly gives some indication of what to expect
   
2. Dave Dombrowski acknowledges Phillies tried to hire Alex Cora as manager
   
3. Trea Turner gives raw thoughts on Rob Thomson's firing
4. Bryce Harper, José Alvarado react to firing of Rob Thomson
5. Phillies fire Rob Thomson; Don Mattingly promoted to interim manager
   
6. Phillies reportedly signing 17-year-old Korean pitching prospect
   
7. MLB announces 2026 All-Star Week Philadelphia schedule
   
8. Jonathan Bowlan has the most unique entrance song in Phillies history, and it fits him perfectly
   
9. What is the Phillies' uniform schedule?
10. 0-99: The greatest Phillies player in the history of every number